The Season 3 butler was gone before the first guests even checked out
Lewis Herring arrived at Rosecroft Park as one of the most intriguing new additions to the “Vanderpump Villa” Season 3 cast — a trained performer turned butler from Kent, with a backstory that made him someone worth rooting for. He was gone before the first guest group even packed their bags. Here’s what actually happened.
Who Was Lewis Herring?
Lewis was brought on as the estate butler for Season 3, stepping into one of the more high-profile roles on staff. He was English, trained as a performer in London before being poached into butler work, and came in with genuine warmth and a compelling personal history.
In his confessional, he opened up about losing his father while he was away at college. His mom called to tell him, and he described it as the moment that reshaped everything, made him grow up fast, and pushed him to want to get the most out of his life. He wanted to build his own events agency. He had real goals and seemed like exactly the kind of person the show is built around.
Hagen Bach noticed early on that something seemed off. Lewis appeared visibly stressed from the jump, even before service began.
What Happened
It unraveled fast. Production pulled Lisa aside to tell her that Lewis had gone to the talent team office — the room next to the control room, next to the kitchen — and was refusing to film. He told producers he didn’t want the cameras on, and that he wouldn’t go to his room unless they unplugged them. When Lisa tried to get to him, he had already locked himself in a nearby bathroom and wouldn’t come out.
Lisa, to her credit, didn’t just let it go. She tried to follow him, called after him through the door, and when she was told by production that he had physically left the building, she ran down the gravel driveway in heels and jumped in a golf cart yelling his name. She never got to him. He was already gone.
The Real Reason
Lewis didn’t leave over a cast conflict, a workplace blowup, or anything that played out on screen. He left due to overwhelming anxiety. Gabriella Sanon was the one who clued Lisa in. She had noticed it, recognized what was happening, and was the first to name it to the group.
Lewis was simply overwhelmed, and the cameras were a part of what was making it worse. His request to have them removed, the locked bathroom door, the black hoodie pulled up over his face as production walked him out — it pointed to someone in a genuine moment of crisis, not someone making a dramatic exit.
There was no fight. There was no fallout. He was there, and then he wasn’t, and the staff found out the same way viewers did — secondhand, after the fact.
How Lisa Handled It
Lisa called a staff meeting shortly after and asked Hagen to step into Lewis’s shoes and take on the butler duties for the remainder of the season. Marciano, for what it’s worth, immediately said in confessional that he didn’t think Hagen was up to it. Hagen, naturally, accepted and spent the rest of the season reminding everyone he was born for it.
In his own Season 3 finale confessional, Hagen gave Lewis a shoutout when he won the $50,000 bonus. A small moment, but it landed.
One More Thing Worth Noting
Lewis’s backstory — the loss of his dad, the resilience he built from it, the dreams he had for his future — made his departure hit differently than a typical cast exit. He came in with something to prove and something to work toward, and anxiety cut the season short before any of that got to play out on screen. Whatever comes next for him, the door at Rosecroft Park apparently opened and closed faster than anyone expected.
UPDATE: What the ‘Vanderpump Villa’ Reunion Revealed About Lewis Herring
New insight into Lewis Herring’s exit came during the “Vanderpump Villa” reunion — and it complicates the narrative around why he left.
When asked whether Gabriella’s leadership style played a role, Chef Anthony revealed that he had spoken to Lewis after filming, including meeting him in London. According to him, Lewis believed the situation “was going to fail” because he wasn’t receiving enough support.
Lisa Vanderpump immediately pressed for clarity, asking if Lewis had said that directly. The chef confirmed he had.
Gabriella pushed back on that version of events, calling the claims “crazy” and framing Lewis’ concerns as complaints about pressure. Other cast members added to the tension, with Meredith noting that Lewis had voiced similar frustrations more broadly.
The reunion also included previously unseen footage showing Gabriella delegating responsibilities to Lewis across multiple situations — including directing him to check tables, manage timing for dinner service, and take ownership of key operational decisions. A confessional from Dom supported that perspective, saying the dynamic felt like Gabriella was “just putting things on him.”
At the same time, Keviah offered a different layer to the story, suggesting Lewis’ departure was not solely about his working relationship with Gabriella. She described him as visibly overwhelmed in his final days and emphasized that there were “more factors” behind his decision to leave.
Taken together, the reunion makes it clear that Lewis’ exit wasn’t caused by a single issue — but rather a mix of pressure, responsibility, and dynamics within the team that played out both on and off screen.
All ten episodes of ‘Vanderpump Villa’ Season 3 are streaming now on Hulu.
More ‘Vanderpump Villa’ Content
Catch up on everything leading into the reunion:
- What Are the “Vanderpump Villa” Cast Up to Now?
- Who’s on the Hot Seat at the “Vanderpump Villa” Reunion?
- The Wildest Moments From “Vanderpump Villa” Season 3
- Questions the “Vanderpump Villa” Reunion Needs to Answer
- Everything to Know Before the “Vanderpump Villa” Reunion
- Who Won the Bonuses In “Vanderpump Villa” Season 3?
For more “Vanderpump Villa” content, click here.
Want the daily reality TV drama — no spam, just the good stuff?
Subscribe