Nobody would have predicted at the end of Episode 1 that Ally Lewber and Jimmy Presnell would become the couple “Perfect Match” Season 4 fans are most invested in. They matched by default — last two standing after everyone else had paired off — and spent the next four episodes making a convincing argument that they weren’t going to make it. And yet, here we are.
The comment section on their joint Instagram post the day after the episodes dropped tells the whole story. Fans rooting for them. Castmates cheering them on. Someone asking when the wedding is. Jimmy replying “still planning.”
So how did a couple that formed almost by accident become the ones everyone is pulling for?
They Were Never the Safe Choice
Part of what makes Ally and Jimmy so watchable is that their connection has never felt guaranteed. From day two, when Ally kissed Dave Hand while still matched with Jimmy, the show gave viewers every reason to write them off. Jimmy was visibly annoyed. Ally was sincerely torn. She spent multiple episodes listing the merits of both men in confessionals that included ninth house astrology, smoothies, and a catio — and somehow made all of it feel sincere rather than ridiculous.
The chaos was real. But so was the pull back to each other. Every time it looked like Ally was going to choose Dave, or Jimmy was going to give up waiting, something snapped them back into orbit. Ally told Marissa George she was freaking out because she genuinely didn’t know what to do. The stakes felt real because neither of them was performing — they were both actually in it and actually scared of losing it.
Jimmy Is Easy to Root For
Jimmy Presnell has one of the most likable presences in the villa, and it isn’t because he is perfect. He gave a “a win is a win” answer right before a house vote that cost him significantly in the eyes of the group. He went on a date with Kassy Castillo and came back saying he would have worked tooth and nail for a second date in the real world — and then chose Ally anyway. He isn’t always smooth. He doesn’t always say the right thing.
But he is consistent about Ally in a way that is impossible to miss. He was relieved every time she came back. He was hurt every time she pulled away. He told her she was his favorite person before he said anything else. He is the kind of person who shows what he feels before he figures out how to say it, and that quality reads as genuine in a way that a lot of reality TV contestants never quite manage.
Ally Is the Most Surprising Version of Herself
For VPR viewers, watching Ally spiral in real time on “Perfect Match” has been unexpected — and weirdly endearing. She is a professional astrologer who checked the stars before she walked into the villa and still couldn’t figure out what to do about two men who both liked her.
She opened a sliding glass door on Jimmy’s conversation with Sophie Willett, said “love you,” and walked away repeating “I regret that” three times. She told Dave she wanted to know how serious he was and then asked him to leave when the conversation got uncomfortable.
She is messier on this show than she has ever been on camera, and that messiness has made her more relatable than any composed, measured version of her could have.
Fans are rooting for her because she is clearly trying, clearly feeling everything, and clearly terrified of getting it wrong again after a very public difficult year.
The Moment That Turned the Comments Section
The end of Episode 5 is what sealed it. Ally told Jimmy she had been freaking out, that she missed him, and that she didn’t want to be open anymore. He told her she knew what he wanted and that of course it was her. She sat in his lap. They kissed. Later that night he told her she was his favorite person and said “I love you.” She told him to stop, then said “okay, I love you too.”
It was quiet and unscripted-feeling and completely earned after four episodes of chaos.
The comment section noticed.
However, the next morning, he gave every indication they were still open, and then the mixer happened. Ally kissed Hashim Moore, and the preview for the next episodes shows her kissing Hashim at a separate event while voicing that her heart and her head are not agreeing. So the road isn’t smooth yet.
But Jimmy’s Instagram reply — “still planning” — suggests they got somewhere worth rooting for.
‘Perfect Match” Season 4 Episodes 1-5 are streaming now on Netflix. Episodes 6 & 7 air May 20.
Read next:
- Ally Lewber’s ‘Perfect Match’ Debut Is Completely Different From ‘Vanderpump Rules’
- Jimmy Presnell Hints He & Ally Lewber Are Still Together — and Maybe Planning a Wedding
- Why Did Jimmy Presnell Pick Ally Lewber Over Kassy Castillo on ‘Perfect Match’ Season 4?
- The Most Shocking Moments on ‘Perfect Match’ Season 4 So Far
- ‘Perfect Match’ Season 4 Villains, Heroes & Chaos Agents: Where Every Cast Member Falls
- Where Every Couple Stands Before ‘Perfect Match’ Episode 6
For more “Perfect Match,” click here.
Want the daily reality TV drama — no spam, just the good stuff?
Subscribe
Leave a Reply